Hawaii Judge Challenges SCOTUS Conservatives, Vows Defiance

WHO:

NY Post - Justice Todd Eddins is the judge challenging the Supreme Court.

Fox News - The article refers to the Roberts Court, which includes the conservative justices of the Supreme Court.

WHAT:

NY Post - Justice Todd Eddins accused the Roberts Court of adopting a "colorblind" approach to the equal protection clause.

Fox News - Eddins stated that the Roberts Court is reviving discredited rulings from 1857 and 1896 while dismantling constitutional rights and democracy.

WHERE:

NY Post - The context of the challenge is in Hawaii, where the judge is based.

WHY:

NY Post - Eddins believes the Supreme Court's approach ignores the original purpose of the equal protection clause, which was to protect formerly enslaved Black Americans.

HOW:

Fox News - Eddins expressed his intention to defy the Supreme Court's decisions regarding constitutional rights.

(UPDATED July 19, 2026 04:08 UTC)

Justice Todd Eddins is challenging the Supreme Court, accusing the Roberts Court of adopting a "colorblind" approach to the equal protection clause, which he argues undermines its original purpose of protecting formerly enslaved Black Americans. Based in Hawaii, Eddins claims that the Roberts Court is reviving discredited rulings from the 1857 Dred Scott case and the 1896 Plessy v. Ferguson decision while dismantling constitutional rights and democracy. He has expressed his intention to defy the Supreme Court's decisions regarding these crucial issues.