Lindsay Shiver's Lawyer Challenges Evidence in Murder Plot Case

WHO:

NY Post - Lindsay Shiver, attorney Craig Shirley, Bahamian Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP)

WHAT:

NY Post - Lindsay Shiver is claimed to be not guilty of the alleged crimes against her.

Fox News - Shiver's attorney argues that the Bahamian prosecutors lack jurisdiction over the case.

WHERE:

Fox News - The alleged crime is said to have occurred in the Bahamas, while Shiver was in the U.S.

WHY:

Fox News - The attorney claims that the jurisdiction issue could undermine the prosecution's case against Shiver.

HOW:

NY Post - Craig Shirley stated that there are "legally fatal" evidence issues that debunk the murder plot allegations.

(UPDATED July 26, 2026 16:19 UTC)

Lindsay Shiver has been claimed to be not guilty of the alleged crimes against her, with her attorney, Craig Shirley, arguing that Bahamian prosecutors lack jurisdiction over the case, which is said to have occurred in the Bahamas while Shiver was in the U.S. Shirley further stated that there are "legally fatal" evidence issues that debunk the murder plot allegations, suggesting that the jurisdiction issue could undermine the prosecution's case against her. The situation has drawn attention from both the NY Post and Fox News as the legal battle unfolds.