FCC Warns Networks Over Broadcasts of “Fake Polls”
WHO:
Deadline - FCC Chairman Brendan Carr warned broadcasters about airing “fake polls” or “suppression polls.” President Donald Trump appointed Carr to lead the FCC.
Alternet - Carr said journalists and broadcasters had amplified or aired polls without regard to “basic journalistic ethics” and without telling the public that some polls lacked a “scientific, accurate, or even real basis.”
Alternet - Elizabeth Grattan said, “Broadcast Hoax literally has NOTHING to do with this and News Distortion is defunct.”
Alternet - NBC News threats reporter Kevin Collier said Carr’s statement would probably be “the most outrageous official statement ever made by a sitting FCC director” in any other administration.
Alternet - Media Matters deputy director of rapid response Andrew Lawrence called for safeguards or for Democrats to use the same tactics against Fox News and conservative media if they regain power.
WHAT:
Alternet - Carr said broadcasters could provide viewers with additional context and information about polls, provided they act consistently with FCC regulations.
Alternet - The article said Republicans criticized the Biden administration’s proposed Disinformation Governance Board, calling it “censorship” and comparing it to the “Ministry of Truth” in George Orwell’s *1984*.
Alternet - Marie Blanchard, a retired Justice Department employee, said, “Since when has it become illegal to tell the American people the truth? Trump [is] a failed president.”
Alternet - Jason Gordon called Carr a “political operative” placed “in a position of responsibility.”
Alternet - Robin DesCamp quoted the saying, “If the polls say we are losing, the polls are fake. If we lose the election, the election was rigged,” and described it as the words of “confident and competent civil servants.”
Deadline - Carr warned that airing “fake polls” or “suppression polls” could run afoul of broadcasters’ regulatory obligations.
Alternet - Carr wrote on X that broadcasters are prohibited under their federal licenses from engaging in “News Distortion” or promoting “Broadcast Hoaxes.” He advised them to avoid airing polls that violate regulatory obligations, while saying they could provide viewers with additional poll context consistent with FCC regulations.
Alternet - The article says the federal rule prohibits knowingly broadcasting false information about a crime or catastrophe when the broadcast directly causes substantial public harm.
Alternet - The rule defines public harm as immediate, direct, and actual damage to property or to public health or safety, or diversion of law-enforcement or public-health and safety authorities.
Alternet - The article reports that Fox News polls showed results unflattering to Trump and that those polls were consistent with other independent polling, citing a Los Angeles Times report.
Alternet - The article says Michael Cohen testified that he paid Red Finch Solutions to manipulate online polls in Trump’s favor during the 2016 election.
WHERE:
Alternet - Carr made his statement in a post on X; the warning concerned broadcasters operating under federal licenses in the United States.
WHY:
Alternet - The article said most polls showed Trump had experienced a significant increase in disapproval.
Deadline - Carr has previously discussed the media’s reliance on polling; Trump has often dismissed survey results unfavorable to him.
Alternet - Carr said the FCC was taking the issue seriously because broadcasters are subject to license restrictions on news distortion and broadcast hoaxes.
HOW:
Alternet - Under the cited rule, public harm must begin immediately; it is foreseeable if a licensee could expect it with significant certainty. A “crime” is an act or omission punishable by law; a “catastrophe” is a disaster or imminent disaster involving a violent or sudden event affecting the public.
(UPDATED October 21, 2026 19:21 UTC)
FCC Chairman Brendan Carr warned that broadcasters could violate their regulatory obligations by airing “fake” or “suppression” polls. In a post on X, he said federal licensees are barred from news distortion and broadcast hoaxes, and urged stations to avoid polls that breach FCC rules. Carr said broadcasters may still offer viewers context about polls if they follow the regulations. The cited rule, however, addresses knowingly false claims about a crime or catastrophe that directly cause substantial public harm, such as immediate damage or disruption to emergency services. Critics questioned whether that rule applies to polling and condemned Carr’s warning as political pressure on the media. The dispute comes as polls have shown rising disapproval of President Trump, and some Fox News surveys have produced results consistent with independent polling. Trump has often dismissed unfavorable survey results.
--
(UPDATED October 21, 2026 18:17 UTC)
FCC Chairman Brendan Carr warned broadcasters that airing “fake polls” or “suppression polls” could violate their obligations under federal licenses. In a post on X, Carr said journalists and broadcasters had aired or amplified polls without regard to basic journalistic ethics, including whether the surveys had a scientific or accurate basis. He urged broadcasters to avoid polls that breach regulations, while allowing them to add context for viewers. The FCC rule he cited concerns knowingly broadcasting false information about a crime or catastrophe when it directly causes substantial public harm, such as immediate damage to safety or property. Critics challenged Carr’s interpretation and said the rule has little to do with polls. NBC reporter Kevin Collier called the statement extraordinary, while Media Matters’ Andrew Lawrence urged safeguards and warned Democrats could use similar tactics against conservative media.