Newsom Death Row Commutations Could Open Path to Freedom, DA Warns
WHO:
CNN - Marc Klaas, father of Polly Klaas, called Newsom’s commutation “a shiv in my back.”
CNN - Polly Klaas’s killer is Richard Allen Davis; Polly was 12 when he kidnapped and killed her.
CNN - Syntara Fuller, sister of Michael Lyons, criticized the commutation’s blanket scope.
CNN - Michael Lyons was 8 when he was killed; Robert Boyd Rhoades was convicted of his murder.
CNN - Chris Guerrero, former sergeant of Sacramento County Deputy Danny Oliver, said Oliver’s killer, Luis Bracamontes, will remain alive.
CNN - Paul Wilson said he had wanted the death penalty for his wife’s killer but later changed his mind.
CNN - Former Los Angeles County District Attorney Gil Garcetti said the death penalty is a “failed policy.”
CNN - Bryan Stevenson, founder and executive director of the Equal Justice Initiative, called the death penalty a “flawed, expensive, and error-filled practice.”
NY Post - Los Angeles District Attorney Nathan Hochman warned about the possible consequences of Gov. Gavin Newsom’s death-sentence commutations.
NY Post - The articles describe the affected people as 548 convicted killers or convicted murderers on California’s death row.
Fox News - The inmates include serial killers Randy Kraft and Chester Turner.
NY Post - One article refers to the mother of an 8-year-old who was kidnapped, raped and murdered, and says the decision ignores victims and their families.
WHAT:
Fox News - California district attorneys and law-enforcement unions criticized the commutations, calling them a betrayal of victims’ families.
Fox News - District attorneys said Newsom’s plan overrides juries and ignores victims’ families.
CNN - The California Supreme Court must approve clemency in 382 cases involving prisoners convicted of multiple felonies; opposition groups have pledged court challenges.
CNN - Newsom said his decision followed nearly three decades of opposing state-sanctioned executions and that killing is “incompatible with California’s values.”
CNN - Newsom has held several meetings with victims’ families, law-enforcement officials and his legal team while considering the decision.
CNN - Annie and Jess Nichol said they support ending the death penalty, while still grieving and feeling anger over Polly’s killing.
CNN - The sisters urged redirecting death-row maintenance resources to victim and survivor support.
CNN - Paul Wilson said he now supports clemency after witnessing families endure years of appeals.
CNN - A coalition of victims’ families, law-enforcement and civil-rights leaders commended the commutation.
NY Post - Hochman warned that Newsom’s commutations could eventually allow convicted killers to seek freedom.
AllHipHop - Newsom seeks to replace 548 California death sentences with life without parole; the article describes it as the largest action of its kind.
Fox News - Newsom’s commutation covers 548 inmates, including “10 of the worst” killers, according to the headline.
NY Post - The article characterizes Newsom’s decision as unilateral and says it commutes the death sentences of 548 convicted murderers.
WHERE:
CNN - Polly Klaas was kidnapped from a sleepover in Petaluma, California; her body was found after Davis confessed and led police to it.
CNN - Michael Lyons went missing in Yuba City, California, and his body was found the next day on a riverbank.
NY Post - The warning concerns California death row.
AllHipHop - The sentences are in California.
Fox News - The inmates are on California’s death row.
WHY:
CNN - Newsom said state-sanctioned killing “undermines the foundations of our legal system” and “diminishes each of us.”
CNN - Marc Klaas said the commutation undermines trial and jury outcomes; he also cited California voters’ rejection of death-penalty-ending ballot propositions in 2012 and 2016.
CNN - Annie Nichol said survivors’ anger should not determine public policy.
NY Post - Hochman’s stated concern is that the commutations could create a path for convicted killers to seek freedom.
NY Post - The article says the decision ignores victims and their families.
HOW:
CNN - Davis was convicted of Polly Klaas’s murder, robbery, burglary, kidnapping, false imprisonment and attempted lewd conduct with a minor.
CNN - Newsom issued a three-page open letter explaining the commutation.
AllHipHop - The proposed change is to replace death sentences with life without parole.
NY Post - The commutations are described as a decision made unilaterally by Newsom.
(UPDATED November 7, 2026 17:57 UTC)
California Governor Gavin Newsom is commuting 548 death sentences to life without parole. Victims’ families and law-enforcement groups condemned the move, saying it disregards victims. Newsom says executions undermine California’s values; supporters urge more resources for survivors.
--
(UPDATED November 7, 2026 13:00 UTC)
California Governor Gavin Newsom is commuting 548 death sentences to life without parole. District Attorney Nathan Hochman warns the move could eventually let convicted killers seek freedom. The inmates include serial killers Randy Kraft and Chester Turner, raising concerns for victims’ families.